Look, Aunt May is always on the verge of death. It doesn’t matter what universe poor Peter Parker is in, his beloved old Aunt is always in danger and sometimes, she slips into oblivion. Or gets pushed into oblivion. Yes, she always come backs to life, sometimes when Peter makes a deal with the devil for some reason, but Aunt May’s precarious health has always been an important part of Peter’s story. Not even casting the vivacious actor Marisa Tomei could prevent that fundamental fact.
As effective as many found the sequence in the finished film, there’s no question that the original draft would have packed a stronger punch. While we viewers have a relationship with Dafoe’s Goblin and know the chaos he caused for a different Peter, Holland’s Parker knows him only as a guy he tried to help who turned on him. It feels more like a random bad thing in Peter’s life (which, admittedly, is part of the ol’ Parker luck).
A post shared by Phil Langone (@phil_langone)
Conversely, Mysterio has a much stronger connection to the MCU Peter. Quentin Beck arrived in Peter’s life just when he needed to fill the gap left by Tony Stark’s death. He took Peter under his wing, showed him not only how to be a hero but also dangled in front of him the possibility of relieving the great responsibility of being Spider-Man. Then he betrayed Peter, shattering all expectations, and placed more burdens on Spidey by revealing his identity. In short, Mysterio had already done so much damage to Peter’s life that we understand why Peter would feel justified in killing him, even before May’s death.
Whatever value this version of the story would have had, it’s clear that Kevin Feige and Marvel wanted to go the Multiverse route and borrow beats from another franchise’s story. It remains to be seen if that decision will lead to better MCU Spider-Man stories in the future.
